When Tempers Flare: Liability Arising from Deposition Fight?

Litigation can get heated. Tempers may flare when the stakes are high and the result can be contentious exchanges amongst counsel. Sure, the adversarial nature of litigation is to be expected (and welcomed by some practitioners), but there is a line in the sand. Some cross that line and make things personal. What to do when things spiral out of control? Can insults form the basis for a separate suit amongst counsel?

The New York Appellate Division considered this issue and concluded that a particularly …

Continue Reading

The Confess and Sue Method

In a previous post we recently discussed legal malpractice claims arising from an underlying settlement. In such “settle and sue” cases, some civil litigants are driven by buyer’s remorse, doubt, or other regret and conclude that they’ve given too much or accepted too little. Eventually, they make a “u-turn” and point the finger at their former attorney. A recent decision proves that similar regret may arise in the criminal context as well. We’ll call it the “confess and sue” malpractice claim.

In Cortez v.

Continue Reading

The “Settle and Sue” Method

They say that a truly good settlement is one that leaves everyone unhappy. There is plenty of truth here. But some settling parties take their unhappiness to a new level by filing a malpractice claim. Whether it be buyer’s remorse, doubt, or the opportunity to reconsider the settlement without the distraction of active litigation, some settling parties determine that they took too little or gave too much away. This may be a part of the uncertainty of compromise and often dissipates over time without …

Continue Reading

Legal Zoom’s Business Model Prompts Ethical Debate

As the legal industry evolves, attorneys and would-be clients continue to experiment with alternatives to the standard law firm model. Some websites offer do-it-yourself standardized legal forms for basic legal needs such as will preparation, lease agreements or corporate formation documents. You’ve probably seen the commercials for Legal Zoom, Nolo, RocketLawyer and others. But, what is actually for sale? Has an attorney drafted these documents? If so, are these attorneys subject to professional malpractice exposure? If not, are these sites engaged in the …

Continue Reading

Alternative Litigation Financing Sparks Malpractice Claim

A modern-day offshoot of the contingency fee arrangement is “alternative litigation financing.” Also known as third-party litigation financing, A.L.F. is the practice of making cash advances, usually to a litigant, to be repaid from the proceeds from the litigation. There is plenty of room for debate the pros and cons of this developing trend. Supporters may argue that this practice allows an injured plaintiff to take an “advance” on an anticipated recovery to address financial hardship before reaching a settlement or verdict. This is particularly …

Continue Reading

Closing Arguments: It’s Business, Nothing Personal

If trial is a performance, than the closing arguments is clearly the final act.  Attorneys channel their inner-actor and perform for the jury with an eye toward persuading the fact-finders to rule in their client’s favor.  Every attorney has a personal style during closings. Some are assertive, some conservative.  Many attorneys look for creative ways to convey their points.  However, there is significant risk that unusual closings may go too far and jeopardize the case, or worse. Take for example the recent reversal of …

Continue Reading

Failure to Disclose Health Condition is Grounds for Malpractice

Attorneys have an ethical duty to keep a client reasonably informed about the status of the representation.  The rules of professional conduct generally require a lawyer to provide the client with sufficient information to participate intelligently in decisions concerning the objectives of the representation.  Fulfilling this ethical obligation, however, may sometimes require the attorney to inform the client about personal matters that may affect the attorney’s ability to represent the client’s interest. For example, an attorney may be obligated to disclose her own health condition …

Continue Reading

Insider Trading at Law Firms? You Bet.

Law firms house a treasure trove of sensitive documents, confidential information, trade secrets and other materials of immeasurable value. Most professionals are aware of these risks and take steps to safeguard cyber and hard copy materials. Yet, the frightening ease with which materials land in the wrong hands was made public recently when a stock broker and a law firm employee were arrested on charges of fraud in connection with  a $33 million insider trading scheme. 

According to reports, here is how the scheme …

Continue Reading

Lying During Settlement Negotiations

Attorneys are bound by strict ethical rules that mandate truthfulness in statements to others. However, when it comes to settlement discussions, many attorneys channel their inner Pinocchio and lie, exaggerate, mislead, bluff, bend the truth, and misrepresent. In an effort to be a zealous advocate and obtain a favorable result for our clients, attorneys must negotiate without revealing the true bottom line.  But, there is a point when a little lie is actually an ethical violation. Where does the line fall between puffery and improper …

Continue Reading

Attorney Reprimanded for Criticizing Out-of-State Judges

Attorneys are expected to show the utmost respect when appearing before the judiciary.  There is a line that differentiates zealous advocacy and disrespect. In a recent decision, a New Jersey attorney learned a valuable lesson about bad mouthing the court, even if that court sits in another jurisdiction.

The case arises from a New Jersey attorney who tried a case in Pennsylvania state court against a company that provided dispute resolution services.  When the state court trial and appellate court judges ruled against the …

Continue Reading